Appearance before the Standing Committee on the Status of Women regarding the Red Dress Alert, April 18, 2024
Table of contents
- 1. Scenario Note
- 2. Opening Remarks
- 3. Canada-wide Emergency Alert System
- 4. Roundtables (FPT and Indigenous Leadership and Representatives)
- 5. Progress on MMIWG Calls to Justice
- 6. Ombudsperson/Tribunal
- 7. Genocide allegation response
- 8. First Nations and Inuit Policing Program
- 9. Human Trafficking
- 10. Prairie Green Landfill Search (R&P)
- 11. Addressing the Calls for Justice on Extractive and Development Industries
- 12. Overall investments since 2015
- 13. Sunsetting Funding
- 14. Truth and Reconciliation Commission Calls to Action
1. Scenario Note
Logistics
Date: April 18, 2024
Time: 3:30pm - 5:30pm
Location: Room 330 Wellington Building (197 Sparks St.)
Subject: Red Dress Alert
Appearing
Panel 1
Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC)
Gary Anandasangaree, Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations
Valerie Gideon, Deputy Minister, Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada
Krista Apse, Director General, MMIWG Secretariat
Public Safety Canada (PS)
Kenza El Bied, Director General, Policy and Outreach Directorate
Arjun Vinodrai, Senior Director, Policy and Programs Development
Panel 2
Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada (CIRNAC)
Valerie Gideon, Deputy Minister, Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada
Krista Apse, Director General, MMIWG Secretariat
Public Safety Canada (PS)
Kenza El Bied, Director General, Policy and Outreach Directorate
Arjun Vinodrai, Senior Director, Policy and Programs Development
Committee Membership
Karen Vecchio (CPC - ON) (Chair)
Michelle Ferreri (CPC - ON)
Anna Roberts (CPC - ON)
Dominique Vien (CPC - QC)
Sonia Sidhu (Lib - ON) (Vice-Chair)
Lisa Hepfer (Lib - ON)
Emmanuella Lambropoulos (Lib - QC)
Marc G. Serré (Lib - ON)
Anita Vandenbeld (Lib - ON)
Andréanne Larouche (BQ - QC) (Vice-Chair)
Leah Gazan (NDP - MB)
Parliamentary Analysis
- Karen Vecchio (CPC) (Chair) will likely support a Red Dress Alert. She may ask questions about the accessibility of shelters and medical care on reserves.
- Michelle Ferreri (CPC) will likely support a Red Dress Alert. She may ask questions related to human trafficking risks, especially for Indigenous youth, as well as Friendship Centres. She may frame the National Action Plan a failure.
- Dominique Vien (CPC) will likely support a Red Dress Alert. She will likely ask questions about the rising rates of violence and human trafficking of Indigenous women and girls, especially in areas near natural resource industries.
- Sonia Sidhu (Lib) (Vice-Chair) will likely support a Red Dress Alert. She may ask questions about the Government's actions towards the Calls for Justice, restricting access to firearms, domestic and intimate partner violence, and funding for shelters and women's centres.
- Lisa Hepfer (Lib) is the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister for Women and Gender Equality and Youth. She may ask questions about gender-based violence and intimate partner violence.
- Emmanuella Lambropoulos (Lib) may ask questions about funding to prevent violence against Indigenous women, girls, and two-spirited people, as well violence near resource developments.
- Marc G. Serré (Lib) is the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of Energy and Natural Resources and to the Minister of Official Languages. He may ask questions about how this affects the mining and forestry industries in northern Ontario, including his riding in Nickel Belt.
- Anita Vandenbeld (Lib) is the Parliamentary Secretary to the Minister of International Development. She may ask questions about access to safe housing and risks of human trafficking.
- Andréanne Larouche (BQ) (Vice-Chair) will likely support a Red Dress Alert. She may ask questions about the risks of human trafficking near resource developments in Western Canada and the cultural genocide against Indigenous peoples. She may also speak about the need for funding for Indigenous-centered community health and wellness centres, women's economic empowerment, and infrastructure on reserves. She will likely tie her questions to the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls' Calls for Justice and UNDRIP, including the call for a national Indigenous ombudsperson and human rights tribunal.
- Leah Gazan (NDP) will likely support a Red Dress Alert, and bring up her Red Dress Alert motion and PM Trudeau's acknowledgement that MMIWG is a genocide. She will ask questions about funding issues, including the sunsetting of $7.6 billion in funding over the next five years, how only 5% of funding for the Violence Prevention Strategy to Address the Crisis of Murdered and Missing Indigenous Women and Girls has been spent in the three years since it was announced ($37.1 million out of a $724.1 million fund), and the cutting of $150 million from women's shelters. She may also ask about how no new shelters or transitional homes have been built and the need to search the Prairie Green Landfill. She will likely highlight the need for action rather than being stuck in months of consultations, supporting youth organizations doing fronting work, the need for action to be directed and led by Indigenous peoples, and tie MMIWG to related issues, such as housing, mental health care, guaranteed livable basic income, and an Indigenous ombudsperson and human rights tribunal.
Context
On November 27, 2023, FEWO set their upcoming committee business, which agreed:
That, pursuant to Standing Order 108 (2), the committee undertake a study on the implementation of a distinct emergency alert system, hereby called the Red Dress Alert, to notify and ask the public for assistance in finding a missing Indigenous woman, girls and 2SLGBTQQIA+ including an examination of a most effective and efficient manner to operate, administer, and control such alert system; that a minimum of four meetings be held on this study; and that the committee report its findings to the House.
On May 2, 2023, MP Leah Gazan (NDP) moved the following motion:
That, given that:
- on October 27, 2022, the House unanimously recognized that what happened in residential schools was genocide,
- decades of insufficient action from all levels of government have failed to address the effects of this genocide, including the crisis of violence against indigenous women, girls, and two-spirit people with the urgency it deserves,
- families in Winnipeg and throughout the country continue to experience the tragic loss of loved ones to this crisis,
the House call on the government to:
- declare the continued loss of indigenous women, girls and two-spirit people a Canada-wide emergency; and
- provide immediate and substantial investment, including in a red dress alert system, to help alert the public when an indigenous woman, girl or two-spirit person goes missing.
On December 15, 2022, Bill S-219, An Act respecting a National Ribbon Skirt Day, received royal assent. In debate on this bill, MPs brought up several topics that overlap with discussions on the Red Dress Alert. Notably, conversation centered around reconciliation, MMIWG, loss of Indigenous culture, female empowerment, child welfare, Friendship Centres, housing and water crises, and addictions and healing supports. The impacts and results of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal Peoples (RCAP), National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls, and the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada (TRC).
Recent Appearances at FEWO
- May 20, 2022: CIR Minister Marc Miller and CIRNAC officials appeared for the study on Resource Development and Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls.
- February 4, 2022: CIRNAC and ISC officials appeared for the study on Intimate Partner and Domestic Violence in Canada
Recent FEWO studies, reports and government responses
- Human Trafficking of Women, Girls and Gender Diverse People (last met on November 27, 2023)
- Resource Development and Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls (report presented on December 14, 2022; Government Response presented on March 31, 2023)
- Intimate Partner and Domestic Violence in Canada (report presented on June 17, 2022; Government Response presented on October 7, 2022)
In the Media
- Landfill search: Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs says further research complete | CTV News
- Ottawa starts work on alert system for missing Indigenous women, girls and two-spirit people | CBC News
- Open letter from the Coalition on MMIWG in BC regarding the National Inquiry - The Smithers Interior News (interior-news.com)
- We'koqma'q First Nation raises signs as part of MMIWG campaign | CBC News
Meeting Proceedings
The meeting is scheduled for April 18, 2024 from
The Chair will call the meeting to order and provide instructions for the meeting proceedings. They will then introduce the witnesses and invite the Minister to deliver opening remarks. This will be followed by a Q&A period (details below).
It is recommended that all speakers speak slowly and at an appropriate volume to ensure they are heard by the interpreters. All witnesses are asked to mute their microphones unless they are speaking.
Following the opening remarks, there will be rounds of questions from Committee members (as listed below). The rounds of questioning will repeat when the second panel commences in the second hour.
Committee members will pose their questions in the following order:
- First round (6 minutes for each Party)
- Conservative Party of Canada
- Liberal Party of Canada
- Bloc Québécois
- New Democratic Party of Canada
- Second round
- Conservative Party of Canada (5 minutes)
- Liberal Party of Canada (5 minutes)
- Bloc Québécois (2.5 minutes)
- New Democratic Party of Canada (2.5 minutes)
- Conservative Party of Canada (5 minutes)
- Liberal Party of Canada (5 minutes)
The meeting can be watched via ParlVU, however there may be an up to 70-second delay with the webcast.
Other Information for Appearing In-Person
- Witnesses should arrive early to allow time for security screening. Screening could take 30 minutes or more for those without a Hill pass.
2. Opening Remarks
Kwe kwe, Ullukkut [Ood-loo-koot], Tansi, hello, bonjour.
I would like to acknowledge that we are on the unceded traditional territory of the Algonquin Anishinaabeg people.
Thank you all for the work you have done on this important initiative. This committee has been incredibly effective over the years – and that's thanks in large part to former Chair Karen Vecchio. Thank you Karen for all the work you did to keep this committee efficient and effective in its important work.
I would also like to thank my colleague from Winnipeg Centre (Leah Gazan) for kickstarting this process, for her strong advocacy for Indigenous women and girls every day — and for always holding my feet to the fire. And also a huge thank you to Pam Damoff – who has been an advocate every step of the way for a Red Dress Alert.
This work will save lives.
As we all know, Budget 2024 included an investment of $1.3 million to continue developing the Red Dress Alert – this is exciting news that will keep the momentum going.
Every Indigenous person who goes missing and is not found, is a failure on our part.
I know there will be some people who are frustrated at the pace of implementing an alert – there are some people who say it can be done overnight.
I do not subscribe to that belief. We need to keep the pressure on and move quickly, but we also have to get this right.
There are many factors to consider, as you have heard through this study. Those include:
- Different regional contexts
- Strained relationships between communities and law enforcement
- Jurisdictional considerations
Moving the dial on this is not an option or a choice, it is a moral imperative.
Despite only making up 4% of the Canadian population, Indigenous women and girls represent 28% of homicides perpetrated against women.
An Indigenous woman is 12 times more likely to go missing or be murdered than a non-Indigenous woman.
Alerting systems in states like California and Washington are helping locate people – and studies show us that the hours after someone goes missing are the most critical to finding them.
In February, I drove the entire Highway of Tears. I sat with and listened to grassroots organizers on the frontline – the Tears to Hope Society who you heard from earlier this week among them.
Alongside a Red Dress Alert, they stressed the importance of solving this systemic crisis. At the Denny's where we had breakfast that morning, the women told me about how important ceremony is to them, and how important it is to pass along traditions and languages to the next generation.
In 2016, our Liberal government called a National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls – after years of the previous government refusing.
This June will mark five years since the National Inquiry released its Final Report – and the Calls to Justice.
The 231 Calls to Justice require investments in shelters, community safety, culture, housing, infrastructure. We are making progress in all these areas – and Budget 2024 was another example of that.
But I say this all the time: the Calls to Justice are not a checklist. They require urgent, sustained action, and commitment from all parties.
They are long-term, structural changes that help us undo the legacy of colonialism. This work is critical, and it will not happen overnight.
Eventually, the hope is to get to a place where we no longer need a Red Dress Alert. Or in other words, we build a future where Indigenous Peoples are safe. The Government will be a partner in that journey.
I thank everyone who has contributed so far to informing the future path. Your work is invaluable.
Meegwetch. Qujannamiik [Koo-ya-na-meek]. Marsee. Merci.
3. Canada-wide Emergency Alert Systems
a. Broadcast, Nationwide: Red Dress Alert
Key Messages
- In May 2023, the House of Commons unanimously backed a motion by MP Gazan to declare the murders and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls a Canada-wide emergency and called on the Government to fund a Red Dress Alert. The intent of a Red Dress Alert would be to alert the public when an Indigenous woman, girl, or 2SLGBTQI+ person goes missing. Such an alert would request the assistance of the public in locating the missing Indigenous woman, girl or 2SLGBTQI+ person quickly and to help ensure that they are located safe in a timely way.
- Pre-engagement sessions with national Indigenous organizations, regional organizations, technical experts, family members, Survivors, and grassroots service providers across the country took place in December 2023 and January 2024 to discuss their views on a Red Dress Alert. Budget 2023 committed to advancing discussions surrounding the Red Dress Alert at the National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ People, which took place in February 2024.
- Advancing a Red Dress Alert pilot is a priority for the Government of Canada. The Government of Canada is continuing exploratory discussions to understand and respond to concerns participants expressed related to mandatory/broadcast alert models during the pre-engagement sessions and feedback provided at the National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable. Some of these concerns included negative public perception related to intrusive alerts that could further entrench harmful attitudes towards Indigenous persons.
Background
- In general, public alerting systems are meant to provide a means of delivering trusted information to notify the affected population about an emergency situation, so that they understand the incident and risk and can take responsive protective action(s).
- The system for the mandatory distribution of public emergency alerts in Canada is the National Public Alerting System (NPAS), also known as, "Alert Ready", which is governed by the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunications Commission and federal, provincial and territorial governments.
- Federal, provincial, and territorial governments determine who may issue NPAS alerts within their respective jurisdiction. These alerting authorities decide when to issue an emergency alert, the alert type, the message content, its duration and geographical areas affected.
- Alerts sent through this system are text and audio-based. Those designated as Broadcast Immediate are accompanied by a distinct alarm sound, and sent to wireless devices connected to a long-term evolution (LTE) network in a specified area, as well as broadcast over radio and television, interrupting programing. Alerts can include a range of imminent or unfolding dangers, such as tornadoes, wildfires, hazardous chemical spills, and civil emergencies.
- There are two types of alerts under the NPAS:
- Broadcast Immediate: represent an imminent threat to life and can only be issued by authorized government officials. The types of events which can be designated for immediate broadcast are established by Federal, Provincial, Territorial Senior Officials Responsible for Emergency Management (SOREM), within CRTC's regulatory framework. This collection of event types and associated conditions for urgency, severity and certainty is known as the Broadcast Immediate Events List. To date, an Amber Alert and a Silver Alert in Quebec (on a pilot-basis) are alert types available for missing persons on the Broadcast Immediate Events List.
- Non-Broadcast Immediate: are also sent by authorized government officials through the NPAS but are not required to be distributed to the public through wireless devices, television, and radio. An example is the SaskAlert App and website that links the Government of Saskatchewan and Environment and Climate Change Canada (ECCC), as the lead agency responsible to issue all types and levels of weather-related alerts, including advisories and special weather statements, watches and warnings.
- Pelmorex (also responsible for the Weather Network) is the technical provider of the Alert Ready system.
- During pre-engagement discussions with Indigenous partners, divergence existed on whether an alert should mobilize mandatory alerts (ie. Similar to an Amber Alert) with the associated challenges of rigid issuing criterions and authorities, opt-in alerts developed with greater flexibility with community, or a joint system of the two, which has never previously been combined in a system to issue and share alerts.
Current Status
- The National Public Alerting System could be a distribution channel for a Red Dress Alert and is included in the discussions and considerations for a Red Dress Alert, alongside other models such as Apps, websites, and opt-in text messaging approaches.
- The Government of Canada recognizes there are challenges and barriers in the reach of public alerting systems and the importance of robust communications infrastructure to support emergency response should not be underestimated. Along with provincial and territorial partners, the Government is committed to continuing to strengthen the overall use, sustainability, continuity of service, and governance of the National Public Alerting System across all-hazards.
- The Government of Canada will continue to provide a leadership role and collaborate with all public alerting stakeholders to improve the effectiveness and ensure the continuity of the NPAS to ensure Canadians have the critical information they need during emergencies.
- CIRNAC will continue to explore a variety of federal, provincial/territorial and Indigenous partners, as well as providers of alert systems, and will work with Indigenous partners to implement a potential alert.
b. Non-broadcast Alerts and Platforms
Key Messages
- In May 2023, the House of Commons unanimously backed a motion by MP Gazan to declare the murders and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls a Canada-wide emergency and called on the Government to fund a Red Dress Alert. The intent of a Red Dress Alert would be to alert the public when an Indigenous woman, girl, or 2SLGBTQI+ person goes missing. Such an alert would request the assistance of the public in locating the missing Indigenous woman, girl or 2SLGBTQI+ person quickly and to help ensure that they are located safe in a timely way.
- Pre-engagement sessions with national Indigenous organizations, regional organizations, technical experts, family members, Survivors, and grassroots service providers across the country took place in December 2023 and January 2024 to discuss their views on a Red Dress Alert. Budget 2023 committed to advancing discussions surrounding the Red Dress Alert at the National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ People which took place in February, 2024.
- Advancing a Red Dress Alert pilot is a priority for the Government of Canada. The Government of Canada is continuing exploratory discussions to identify different models, including voluntary, community led opt-in models that could be managed through apps, websites or other mechanisms, that respond to "What We Heard" during the pre-engagement sessions and feedback provided at the National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable.
Background
- Indigenous women, girls, and 2SLGBTQI+ people continue to go missing and are murdered at alarming rates. Based on annual data from Statistics Canada, despite only making up 4 per cent of the Canadian population, Indigenous women and girls represent 28 per cent of homicides perpetrated against women in 2019 and are 12 times more likely to be murdered or missing than non-Indigenous women in Canada. Data from Statistics Canada's Homicide Survey show that the rate of homicide among Indigenous women in 2019 was more than 7 times higher than among non-Indigenous women, at 4.01 per 100,000 population compared with 0.55 per 100,000 population —a number that is even higher for Inuit women and Indigenous women in the North.
- In response to the motion declaring the murders and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls a Canada-wide emergency and calling on the Government to fund a Red Dress Alert, CIRNAC organized sixteen pre-engagement sessions in December 2023 and January 2024 to solicit preliminary feedback on the Red Dress Alert from national Indigenous organizations, regional organizations, technical experts, family members, Survivors, and grassroots service providers across the country. During the second National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on February 7 and 8, 2024, "What Was Heard" during the pre-engagement sessions was presented and participants further discussed considerations for the Red Dress Alert. There is a need for a critical and immediate response to the national emergency and a great interest from Indigenous communities in advancing a Red Dress Alert.
- There are a variety of different forms that a Red Dress Alert could take, such as an automatic widespread broadcast alert, or a voluntary opt-in alert that could be managed through apps, websites or other mechanisms. Broadcast immediate alerts, such as Amber Alert, are distributed through the National Public Alerting SystemFootnote 1. There are other alert systems and distribution channels such as applications (apps) or websites that exist at national, regional, or local levels and require an individual or organization to opt-in to receiving alerts. CIRNAC is continuing to explore these options and models with governments, organizations and communities, as well as the technical providers who support them, who have experience with various opt-in emergency alerting systems, including those identified below.
- Unama'ki Emergency Alert System (Mass Notification System) - serves the Mi'kmaq communities in the Union of Nova Scotia (Cape Breton) and uses the SMS, call (landline) and email function to send out alerts for missing persons, weather or emergency situations via the Everbridge system. Community Chiefs and Elders were engaged to create loose parameters for the criteria of the alert.
- Rescu App (Application-based) – assists police and families in active and ongoing searches for missing children across Canada. Users can subscribe to receive SMS text alerts on new cases in their area and submit tips on existing cases. The app has been developed by the Missing Childrens Society of Canada, and also includes a network that allows communities to easily communicate online.
- Talking Stick App/First Alert App First Alert is an extension to the original Talking Stick app owned by the Federation of Sovereign Indigenous Nations and provides a community-driven emergency alert system by Indigenous, for Indigenous people. First Alert quickly shares culturally sensitive emergency information to Indigenous communities on issues including missing persons, natural disasters, or threats to public safety. It is a community-based and community operated system where subscribers opt-in. It has gone live in James Smith Cree Nation and is rolling out to several other First Nations in Saskatchewan.
- Missing Indigenous Person Alert (PDF) (US – Washington State Patrol) (Web-based, Traditional Media and Digital Signage): Working with tribal law enforcement, municipal and federal law enforcement, Washington State Department of Transportation (WSDOT) and other state agencies, as well as cable systems and state broadcasters, WSP's Missing and Unidentified Persons Unit (MUPU) have added the specific designation of Missing Indigenous Persons to the Endangered Missing Alerts Systems already in place. Alerts are shared via social media, highway signs, highway advisory radio system and via email and fax to a list of subscribers.
- Other platforms include: Aboriginal Alert (Web-based): Continually shares information about missing Indigenous individuals in Canada and works together with organizations to provide resources and supports for individuals in need who are seeking help. Information is also shared on Facebook and X (previously known as Twitter); and "Find your Loved One" (FYLO) (app is a partnership between the City of Vancouver's MMIWG2S team and 7GenAiO Tech Corp, an Indigenous-run technology company) that aims to provide a comprehensive platform to support families and survivors during the search, investigation and follow up process after the disappearance of a loved one.
Current Status
- Technical conversations on a Red Dress Alert are ongoing to explore models with federal, provincial, territorial, and Indigenous partners - as well as providers of alert systems.
c. Cross-border considerations
Key Messages
- In May 2023, the House of Commons unanimously backed a motion by MP Leah Gazan to declare the murders and disappearances of Indigenous women and girls a Canada-wide emergency and called on the Government to fund a Red Dress Alert. The intent of a Red Dress Alert would be to alert the public when an Indigenous woman, girl, or 2SLGBTQI+ person goes missing. Such an alert would request the assistance of the public in locating the missing Indigenous woman, girl or 2SLGBTQI+ person quickly and to help ensure that they are located safe in a timely way.
- Pre-engagement sessions with national Indigenous organizations, regional organizations, technical experts, family members, Survivors, and grassroots service providers across the country took place in December 2023 and January 2024 to discuss their views on a Red Dress Alert. Budget 2023 committed to advancing discussions surrounding the Red Dress Alert at the National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ People which took place in February 2024.
- The complexity of navigating cross-jurisdictional issues such as when victims or perpetrators cross provincial and territorial borders, and survivors, families and loved ones need to work across jurisdictional borders to get support has been raised in engagements on a Red Dress Alert. Advancing the Red Dress Alert is a priority for the Government of Canada and these and other cross-border and jurisdictional issues will inform the approach to advancing a Red Dress Alert.
Background
- Following the Red Dress Alert pre-engagement sessions that took place in December 2023 and January 2024, as well as discussions during the second National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial (IFPT) Roundtable on February 7-8, 2024, both Indigenous and provincial and territorial partners identified cross-jurisdictional issues as an anticipated obstacle to creating a Red Dress Alert. Partners emphasized that a lack of communication across jurisdictional and provincial authorities can prevent families and loved ones from accessing critical information that would help them find missing persons in a timely way.
- In Canada, cross-jurisdictional complexities can arise when MMIWG victims and perpetrators easily and seamlessly cross provincial and territorial borders. Law enforcement agencies have means to work together across Provincial/Territorial and international lines through the Canadian Police Information Centre.
- Indigenous women and girls are over-represented as victims of sexual exploitation and trafficking. International border crossings should also be considered when looking at cross-border issues as HT takes place domestically as well as internationally (when a victim cross an international boundary). For further information on Human Trafficking, see Issue Sheet 9 in this binder.
- Many alerts that are currently in use are also limited within provincial borders - information is not easily shared across jurisdictions. For example, when an Amber Alert is issued, the necessary information is provided to the public via media (radio and television), and wireless devices (cell phones) in a targeted area. Alerts are issued provincially, and cross-jurisdictional issuance of alerts requires cross-provincial collaboration; in some instances, cellphones connected to cellphone towers across provincial borders may receive alerts from other provinces.
- Frequently, Indigenous women, girls and two-spirit individuals move away from their communities to different province or territory. When these individuals are reported missing, it is difficult for family and loved ones living in a different province/territory to make a missing persons report; there is uncertainty of which law authority would be responsible, thus standing in the way of issuing an alert as soon as possible.
- Cross-jurisdiction support is also needed at the community level as many partners have called for the need of wrap around supports to be launched alongside a Red Dress Alert. Resources are needed such as shelters, safe spaces and mental health supports across provinces/territories when victims have been taken across borders.
- Search and rescue (SAR) efforts led at the community level also require cross jurisdictional support from authorities when SAR efforts cross provincial or international (US) borders.
- In Canada, Amber Alerts are one of the most well-known alerts sent through the National Public Alerting System and other alerting channels. They are issued provincially/territorially, and cross-jurisdictionally through cross-provincial/territorial collaboration, if a child is abducted and there is reason to believe they could have been transported across provincial/territorial borders. They are issued by law enforcement when a child is abducted and provides the public with immediate and up-to-date information about the abduction and solicits the public's help in the safe and swift return of the child.
Current Status
- Technical conversations are ongoing to explore various alerting models with federal, provincial/territorial and Indigenous partners, as well as providers of alert systems. Addressing cross-jurisdictional issues will continue to be considered as options are developed.
4. Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls, and 2SLGBTQI+ People
Key Messages
- The Second Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial (IFPT) Roundtable took place on February 7-8, 2024. It brought together over 100 in-person and 130 virtual participants, from Indigenous national, regional and women's organizations, grassroots organizations and service providers, as well as from federal, provincial and territorial governments.
- The meeting provided productive discussions on: the development of a Red Dress Alert, which took up the majority of day 1; the recommendations by the Ministerial Special Representative on an Indigenous and Human Rights ombudsperson (Call for Justice 1.7); and, provincial and territorial approaches to oversight and monitoring of Calls for Justice implementation. It ended with a broader discussion with a leadership on opportunities for collaboration. A report of the meeting will be available in Spring 2024, and CIRNAC is starting the planning for the next meeting, to be held in winter 2025.
Background
- Budget 2023 committed $2.5 million over five years to facilitate and coordinate work on advancing the National Action Plan by establishing a standing national Indigenous Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQI+ People, including prioritizing discussion on a Red Dress Alert. The first Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable was held virtually on January 10, 2023.
- The second Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable took place in hybrid format on February 7 and 8, 2024 bringing together over 100 participants in-person in Ottawa and 130 in a virtual capacity.
- The meeting was tri-chaired by Minister Anandasangaree Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations, Government of Canada, Minister Nahanni Fontaine, Minister Responsible for Families, Manitoba, and Hilda Anderson-Pyrz, Chair of the National Family and Survivors Circle. Plenary discussions were moderated by three facilitators (First Nation, Inuit, and Métis).
- The first day of the agenda was focused mostly on a discussion on the Red Dress Alert, including breakout sessions. Such an alert would notify the public when an Indigenous woman, girl or 2SLGBTQI+ person goes missing.
- Sandra Delaronde, co-Chair of Manitoba's MMIWG Implementation Committee, and Hilda Anderson-Pyrz provided an overview of what they heard throughout the 16 regional and distinctions-based pre-engagement sessions on the Red Dress Alert which they had led in December and January, with MP Leah Gazan (Winnipeg Centre) and MP Pam Damoff (Oakville North-Burlington).
- Participants at the IFPT indicated that the development of an alert system must be community-led, and that further continued community consultation is needed. They raised concerns about the strained relationship and lack of trust between Indigenous communities and law enforcement. There was recognition that an alert should include connections to wrap around support services both for family members of a missing person as well as for missing people who are found. This would include things like access to shelters and mental health supports. Overall, participants were supportive of a Red Dress Alert and there was significant interest in further discussions and consultations.
- Following the discussions on the Red Dress Alert, the Ministerial Special Representative on an Indigenous and Human Rights ombudsperson, Jennifer Moore Rattray, also provided a presentation summarizing her final report on the creation of an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson. Ms. Moore Rattray shared that she recommends there be four national Indigenous and Human Rights ombudspersons and 13 regional ones, who should be independent, enshrined in legislation, and adequately funded. Roundtable participants were appreciative of the presentation.
- The second day of the Roundtable began with presentations on oversight and monitoring of implementation of the Calls for Justice by the Government of Alberta, the Government of British Columbia, and the Government of the Yukon. These presentations were well received, and Roundtable participants emphasized the importance of accountability and the need for an oversight body.
- The rest of the day involved a facilitated discussion with leadership, led by the Tri-Chairs. This provided Indigenous leaders and partners, as well as federal and provincial/territorial leadership the opportunity to ask questions and share what their organizations/governments are currently working on, best practices, as well as plans for the future, including opportunities for collaboration. Discussions included a focus on the need for inclusion and collaboration: the implementation of the Calls for Justice requires keeping families and survivors at the centre of the work, and an inclusive approach to collaboration. Other topics raised included the urgent need for housing, including shelters; the need for long-term and sustainable funding for Indigenous organizations; the need for ongoing engagement with Indigenous 2SLGBTQI+ people; the need to empower Indigenous youth and children, including reform of Child and Family Services; the importance of the role of urban supports; the importance of data collection and data sovereignty; the need for prevention; and the inclusion of Indigenous men and boys in this work.
Current Status
- CIRNAC is currently developing the Report of the 2024 Roundtable. The Report will be released publicly in spring/summer 2024. Planning for the 2025 Roundtable is underway, with efforts to incorporate feedback on timing and agenda from 2024 participants. The priorities discussed during the 2024 meeting, will inform the work on the 2025 agenda as well.
- The final version of the MSR's final report was submitted to the Minister in March 2024.
- The department continues to explore the Red Dress Alert.
5. Progress on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls: Calls for Justice
Key Messages
- The National Inquiry's 231 Calls for Justice call upon the whole of Canadian society, including the federal government, provincial and territorial governments, municipalities, Indigenous governments, industries, service providers, and all Canadians to take action to make the systemic changes needed to end the national crisis of missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- As part of the Federal Pathway, over 20 federal departments and agencies are working towards implementing the Calls for Justice where the federal government has a role. The Annual Progress Report, released annually on June 3, provides a snapshot of the progress made and the linkages to the Calls for Justice. The Federal Pathway is a living document that will adapt over time.
- CIRNAC coordinates the work of federal departments and agencies, Indigenous partners and provincial and territorial jurisdictions to advance work on the Calls for Justice through the implementation of the Federal Pathway and engagement with Indigenous partners, provinces, and territories. In addition, the federal government is focusing on advancing two critical Calls for Justice on oversight and accountability, 1.10 and 1.7, as well as exploring options for a Red Dress Alert.
- National Action Plan and the Federal Pathway
- On June 3rd 2019, the National Inquiry released its final report and 231 Calls for Justice. In response, the Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls, and 2SLGBTQQIA+ People National Action Plan (National Action Plan) was released on June 3, 2021 by Indigenous partners and provincial, territorial and federal governments. The National Action Plan is an overarching plan, with a series of contributing partner chapters, which identifies the priorities and immediate next steps that must be taken by all orders of government, organizations, and communities across the country to address violence against Indigenous women, girls, and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- The Federal Pathway to Address Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQI+ People (Federal Pathway), is the federal government's contribution to the National Action Plan. It contains approximately 85 initiatives that are aimed at ending violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- CIRNAC is leading or co-leading on a number of programs that are supporting improvements in areas linked to the Calls for Justice, for instance:
- the Support for Indigenous women's and 2SLGBTQQIA+ organizations program partially responds to Call for Justice 1.8, which calls upon governments to support national, regional, and local Indigenous women's and 2SLGBTQI+ organizations.
- The Indigenous Led Data Research Projects Program/ National Indigenous Data Advisory Group on MMIWG2S+programs support Calls for Justice 5.24, 16.44, 17.2, 18.4, which call for enhancement of research, data collection and monitoring related to MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- Budget 2022 announcements on housing support address Calls for Justice on housing and infrastructure, such as those on Inuit Housing (Calls for Justice 4.1, 4.6, 16.19, 18.25), Métis Housing (CFJs 4.1, 4.6, 16.19, 18.25), Self-Governing and Modern Treaty First Nations Housing (Calls for Justice 4.1, 4.6, 4.7, 16.19, 18.25) and Affordable Housing in the North (Calls for Justice 4.1, 4.6, 4.7, 12.4, 16.1, 16.18, 16.19, 18.25).
- Effective implementation of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act, with support for the capacity development for Indigenous partners to continue to collaborate on the implementation of the Act, including the development, implementation and monitoring of an action plan. This initiative is led by Justice Canada, with CIRNAC support and is linked to Calls for Justice 1 .2v, 1.7, 2.1, 3.1, and 16.43 (related to Indigenous rights, human rights and wellbeing).
- Through these initiatives and others from across the federal government that address the Calls for Justice, concrete progress is being made for Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people in areas such as shelters and housing, education, health care, and wellbeing.
- Reporting/Results/Indicators and Alignment with Other Plans, Strategies and OGD Work
- The Federal Pathway Annual Progress Report is a progress update on the federal government's commitments in the National Action Plan and the corresponding Calls for Justice, published yearly on June 3rd.
- The Horizontal Initiative Results Framework on MMIWG is a whole-of-government document that monitors progress and ensures accountability. It shows combined expenditures, achievement of outcomes and reports to parliamentarians and Canadians.
- CIRNAC will be reporting in the 2024-25 Departmental Results Report on the number of missing and murdered Indigenous women and girls family members and survivors who have received supports from a culturally-relevant provider for their healing journey.
- The Federal Pathway aligns with other national plans and strategies, including the National Action Plan to End Gender-Based Violence, Canada's Anti-Racism Strategy, the Indigenous Justice Strategy, and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act Action Plan.
- CIRNAC MMIWG Secretariat
- Budget 2021 provided support for the establishment of the MMIWG Secretariat ($16M over 6 years), which:
- leads the coordination of the Government of Canada's efforts to address violence against Indigenous women, girls, and Two-Spirit+ people, including the implementation, monitoring, and evaluation of the Federal Pathway;
- engages with Indigenous partners on addressing MMIWG;
- manages the Wellbeing of Families and Survivors Program, the Indigenous-Led Data Program, and supports Indigenous partners to continue to participate in the work going forward; and,
- provides policy direction, development and implementation on issues related to the National Action Plan and Federal Pathway.
- CIRNAC is making progress on Call for Justice 1.7, which calls for an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson and Tribunal. In January 2023, Jennifer Moore Rattray was appointed as the Ministerial Special Representative, and mandated to provide advice in support of developing an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson. The final report was provided to the Minister in March 2024. (This work was supported by $1.6 M over two years from Budget 2023.)
- To advance Call for Justice 1.10 on oversight, CIRNAC has worked with an Indigenous firm to engage Indigenous partners and received a final report from the firm in spring 2023. (Budget 2023 provided $2.2 M over five years to advance this work).
- Budget 2021 provided support for the establishment of the MMIWG Secretariat ($16M over 6 years), which:
- National Action Plan and the Federal Pathway
Current Status
- The second National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ occurred on February 7th and 8th, 2024, with leaders and representatives from national and regional Indigenous partners, and federal, provincial and territorial ministers who shared best practices, discussed monitoring and reporting, and identified priorities for action.
- The third Federal Pathway Annual Progress Report will be published on June 3, 2024 and will report on the progress Federal Pathway initiatives have made towards their corresponding Calls for Justice.
6. Ombudsperson/Tribunal (Call for Justice 1.7)
Key Messages
- Call for Justice 1.7 calls for the establishment of a National indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson and tribunal. To move forward on the implementation of this Call for Justice, on January 10, 2023, then Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations Marc Miller appointed Jennifer Moore Rattray as Ministerial Special Representative (MSR) to provide advice and recommendations, in support of Call for Justice 1.7 to create an Indigenous and Human Rights ombudsperson. Her work was supported by $1.6 M over 2 years from Budget 2023.
- Over the course of 2023, the MSR met with Indigenous governments and organizations across Canada, as well as federal, provincial and territorial officials, to seek views on what an ombudsperson could and should look like. Based on these engagements, she produced a report with recommendations, which she presented during the second national Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on February 7 and 8, 2024. These included recommendations for the establishment of national and regional ombudspersons, to focus on federal services, programs and policies.
- Her final report was submitted in March 2024 and is expected to be publicly released in Spring 2024.
Background
- Call for Justice 1.7 states: "We call upon the federal, provincial, and territorial governments, in partnership with Indigenous Peoples, to establish a National Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson, with authority in all jurisdictions, and to establish a National Indigenous and Human Rights Tribunal. The ombudsperson and tribunal must be independent of governments and have the authority to receive complaints from Indigenous individuals as well as Indigenous communities in relation to Indigenous and human rights violations, and to conduct thorough and independent evaluations of government services for First Nations, Inuit, and Métis people and communities to determine compliance with human and Indigenous rights laws.
- The ombudsperson and the tribunal must be given sufficient resources to fulfill their mandates and must be permanent."
- On January 10, 2023, then Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations Marc Miller appointed Jennifer Moore Rattray as the MSR to provide advice and recommendations, through engagement with survivors, families, partners and organizations, in support of Call for Justice 1.7 to create an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson.
- The MSR met with First Nations, Inuit, and Métis governments and organizations, Indigenous women's and 2SLGBTQI+ organizations, and urban Indigenous organizations - including families and survivors. Meetings were also held with federal, territorial, and provincial partners leading work on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls, Two-Spirit and Gender-Diverse People (MMIWG2S+) to gather information and provide advice and recommendations on the way forward.
- The MSR was independent from the public service and reported directly to the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations. Her contract ended on March 31, 2024.
- The MSR submitted an interim report in October 2023 and she presented her findings during the 2024 National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG and 2SLGBTQI+ People. Her final report was submitted in March 2024.
- The MSRs recommendations include: the establishment of four national Indigenous and Human Rights ombudspersons (distinctions-based and urban), and 13 regional ones, who would be independent, Indigenous-led, enshrined in legislation, and adequately funded.
- The MSR's work has focussed on the recommendation to establish an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson. She references the need for a tribunal as well. Action Plan Measure 19 (under shared priorities) of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act Action Plan focuses on establishing an independent Indigenous rights monitoring, oversight, recourse or remedy mechanism or mechanism. Work undertaken in relation to that action plan, lead by the Minister of Justice, will no doubt be relevant to the human rights tribunal component of Call for Justice 1.7.
Current Status
- The MSRs final report on CFJ 1.7 (an Indigenous and Human Rights Ombudsperson) has been received, and is being reviewed to inform next steps.
- The Final Report is tentatively scheduled for public release in Spring 2024.
7. Genocide allegation response
Key Messages
- The National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls (National Inquiry) found that the violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people amounts to genocide.
- The Government respects the National Inquiry's findings and acknowledges that the legacy of past actions and policies, such as the Indian Act and residential schools, have directly led to the loss and extinguishment of Indigenous languages, cultures, and traditional practices.
- The Government has taken action through policies, programs, legislation and investments to address Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQI+ People, and remains committed to ending this national crisis of violence.
Background
- The National Inquiry's Final Report states that the violence against Indigenous women, girls, and 2SLGBTQI+ people amounts to a "race-based genocide of Indigenous Peoples, including First Nations, Inuit and Métis, which especially targets women, girls and 2SLGBTQQIA people". As part of its Final Report, it released a supplementary report with a legal analysis on genocide. Many families, survivors, and witnesses that shared their truths with the National Inquiry also used the word "genocide" in their testimonies.
- In the days after the release of the National Inquiry's Final Report, at the Women Deliver Conference in 2019, Prime Minister Trudeau stated that "We accept their [the National Inquiry's] findings, including that what happened amounts to genocide." Subsequently, in his speech at the release of the National Action Plan on June 3, 2021, Prime Minister Trudeau reiterated this statement.
- The Federal Pathway includes the National Inquiry's finding of genocide, and reflects the Prime Minister's statement in Vancouver in 2019. It also states that the Government of Canada recognizes that the legacy of federal policies, programs, regulations and laws, created and perpetuate systemic inequities for Indigenous Peoples, including marginalization, higher rates of illness, disability, suicide, food insecurity, poverty, and violence" and "acknowledges that colonialism, racism, sexism and ableism have created systemic inequities for Indigenous Peoples, contributing to the loss and extinguishment of Indigenous languages, cultures and traditional practices, and that these inequities have impacted the rightful power and place of Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQQIA+ people."
- Addressing the national crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQI+ People is a key priority for the Government of Canada, and the Government has taken action as part of the Federal Pathway, working together with Indigenous partners, and coordinating with provinces and territories.
- Actions have included the implementation of programs such as those supporting families and survivors, cultural spaces, health and wellness, languages, shelters, housing, education and data, as reported in the federal annual progress report. Policies and strategies on gender-based violence and violence prevention, equity and equality for 2SLGBTQI+ people, Indigenous justice, and mental health and wellness are being developed and implemented. Legislation on key issues such as Child and Family Services, Indigenous languages and the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous people have been passed.
- The National Indigenous-Federal-Provincial-Territorial Roundtable on MMIWG, which started in 2023, and was enhanced with an in-person component in 2024, provides an annual forum for interjurisdictional discussions, and enhanced collaboration with Indigenous partners.
Current Status
- The Government will continue to do what is right and necessary to honour missing and murdered Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people and to foster the healing of families, survivors, and Indigenous communities.
8. First Nations and Inuit Policing Program
Key Messages
- All Canadians have a right to receive well-funded, culturally responsive, and respectful police services.
- The Government of Canada is working jointly with First Nations partners to gain consensus on common interests and possible solutions to co-develop legislation recognizing First Nations police services as an essential service.
- These efforts support broader work to respond to Call for Justice 5.4 in the Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls calling on "governments to immediately and dramatically transform Indigenous policing from its current state".
Background
- First Nations police services in Canada receive financial support from Public Safety Canada through the First Nations and Inuit Policing Program (FNIPP). Through FNIPP, policing services are supported through tripartite policing agreements among the federal government, provincial or territorial governments, and First Nation or Inuit communities. Costs under FNIPP are shared with provinces and territories in accordance with a 52% federal and 48% provincial/territorial cost-share ratio.
- There are two main types of policing agreements:
- Self-administered Police Service Agreements, where a First Nation or Inuit community manages its own police service under provincial policing legislation and regulations; and,
- Community Tripartite Agreements, where a dedicated group of officers from the Royal Canadian Mounted Police provides policing services to a First Nation or Inuit community.
- There are currently 36 First Nations police services and one Inuit police service across the country, serving 157 communities. These operate in alignment with provincial and territorial policing standards and authorities.
- First Nations in Canada have long called for reform to how First Nations police services are funded and have advocated for federal legislation that recognizes First Nations policing as an essential service.
- The 2021 mandate letters committed the Minister of Public Safety to co-develop federal legislation that recognizes First Nations police services as essential services through equitable, flexible, and sustainable funding, with the support of the Minister of Indigenous Services and the Minister of Crown-Indigenous Relations.
- Through Budget 2021, the Government of Canada announced significant new investments to support culturally responsive policing in Indigenous communities. This new funding includes $540.3 million over five years, beginning in 2021-22, and $126.8 million ongoing, to support First Nations and Inuit communities currently served under the FNIPP and expand the program to new First Nations and Inuit communities.
Current Status
- The Minister of Public Safety is focused on advancing litigation and addressing the core issue of funding.
- The Minister has committed that federal legislation will respect the current mandate of Indigenous police services under the jurisdiction of provincial, territorial, and Indigenous partners. While legislation will provide greater certainty and predictability of the program, it falls short of the position of the Assembly of First Nations. As a result, the AFN has withdrawn from this process.
- First Nations police services face significant challenges and financial obstacles to deliver adequate and culturally appropriate policing services. Public Safety has lead co-development efforts since 2022, including ongoing engagements with First Nations communities, organizations, and police services, Provincial and Territorial partners, and other subject matter experts on these shortcomings.
- The First Nations and Inuit Policing Program is also the subject of active litigation (Pekuakamiulnuatsh First Nation, Indigenous Police Chiefs of Ontario, and l'Association des Directeurs de Police des Premières Nations et Inuit du Québec) on the grounds of underfunding, and discriminatory provisions of a service.
Program-Level Data
- Any questions regarding program related date should be directed to the Minister of Public Safety, Democratic Institutions and Intergovernmental Affairs and the department of Public Safety, who are responsible for FNIPP.
9. Human Trafficking
Key Messages
- The Government of Canada remains committed to the important work of the Trilateral Working Group on Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls.
- On September 6 and 7, 2023, Canada hosted the Fifth Convening of the Working Group alongside United States and Mexico. Government officials and Indigenous leaders from Canada, Mexico, and the United States took part in discussions on two themes: human trafficking and access to justice.
- The Human Trafficking Taskforce, led by Public Safety Canada and comprising key federal departments including Crown Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada, plays a pivotal role in strengthening the Government's response to human trafficking.
Trilateral Working Group on Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls
- CIRNAC as the lead department for the government of Canada hosted the Fifth Convening of the Trilateral Working Group on Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls on September 6 - 7, 2023. Indigenous partners and federal officials from Canada, Mexico and the US held the discussions on two themes: human trafficking and access to justice.
- On human trafficking, all three countries shared recent actions taken to address human trafficking and exploitation within communities and across borders. For Canada, Public Safety was invited to present on Canada's approaches to combat human trafficking.
Human Trafficking Taskforce (HTT)
- Additionally, the CIRNAC international team participates in the interdepartmental Human Trafficking Taskforce (HTT) led by Public Safety Canada, given the links to the trilateral working group on violence against Indigenous Women and Girls.
FEWO report, entitled Act Now: Preventing Human Trafficking of Women, Girls and Gender Diverse People in Canada
- In June 2023, Health Canada solicited input from the MMIWG Secretariat on an MC entitled, "Government Response to the Standing Committee on the Status of Women, Report 6: A Step-by-Step Approach to Supporting the Mental Health of Young Women and Girls in Canada". Input was confined to suggestions for more inclusive language.
- The Standing Committee on the Status of Women resumed its study of the human trafficking of women, girls, and gender diverse people at a committee meeting in November 2023.
- MMIWG Secretariat is representing CIRNAC in government's response to the tenth FEWO report, entitled Act Now: Preventing Human Trafficking of Women, Girls and Gender Diverse People in Canada.
Current Status
- Mexico has assumed chairpersonship of the Trilateral Working Group on Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls as of January 2024. It is anticipated that Mexico will host the official sixth convening later this year. Details are still to be confirmed.
- Crown Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada will continue to support Public Safety Canada on the Human Trafficking Taskforce working group.
10. Prairie Green Landfill
Key Messages
- The violent deaths of Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myran are a tragic reminder of the alarming number of incidences of violence, discrimination and abuse in our country against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people that cannot be ignored.
- The Government of Manitoba has committed $20 million to undertake a search of the Prairie Green Landfill for the remains of Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myran and the Government of Canada also intends to make a commitment.
- A search of the landfill will send a message to all Canadians that First Nation women are important and deserving of respect.
Background
- In December 2022, Winnipeg Police Service informed the families of Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myron, both from Long Plain First Nation, that: the women were the victims of homicide; their remains may have been deposited in the Prairie Green Landfill; and the Winnipeg Police Service did not plan to search the landfill as part of the homicide investigation.
- Jeremy Skibicki has been charged with first degree murder in the deaths of four First Nation women: Morgan Harris, Marcedes Myron, Rebecca Contois, whose partial remains were found in the Brady Road Landfill, and an unidentified woman the community has named Mashkode Bizhiki'ikwe (Buffalo Woman). His trial is scheduled to begin on April 29, 2024.
- In response to sustained calls to search the Prairie Green Landfill for the remains of Morgan Harris and Marcedes Myron, the Government of Canada has consistently messaged that it will work with victims' families, First Nation leadership and the Government of Manitoba to support measures grounded in the intention to do the right thing for Ms. Harris, Ms. Myron and their families.
Current Status
- Ministers Anandasangaree and Vandal attended a meeting on March 22, 2024, convened by the Premier of Manitoba and attended by the Grand Chief of the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs and representatives of the Morgan and Harris families.
- At that meeting, the Premier announced that the Government of Manitoba will make $20 million available to undertake a search of the Prairie Green Landfill.
- It is the intention of the Government of Canada to continue to support measures grounded in the intention to do the right thing for Ms. Harris, Ms. Myron and their families.
Program-Level Data
Program/Investment:
- $500,000
- Funding / Performance Indicator Data
- Provided to the Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs in March 2023, to oversee the development of a study to determine the feasibility of searching the Prairie Green Landfill for the remains of two murdered First Nation women. The Prairie Green Landfill Feasibility Study Report was submitted on May 4, 2023.
- Funding / Performance Indicator Data
- $740,000
- Funding / Performance Indicator Data
- Provided to the Long Plain First Nation in October 2023, to oversee the development of comprehensive and integrated plans to support a search. The Search the Landfill: Inter-related Operational Planning Report was submitted on January 24, 2024.
- Funding / Performance Indicator Data
11. Addressing the Calls for Justice on Extractive and Development Industries
Key Messages
- The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls includes a Deeper Dive on Resource Extraction and five Calls for Justice specific to Extractive and Development Industries.
- My colleague responsible for Natural Resources is uniquely positioned to lead on the collaboration and coordination required to bolster progress on the Calls for Justice by leveraging their longstanding relationships with Indigenous communities and organizations, natural resource sectors and federal, provincial and territorial partners. I am pleased that they have also successfully advocated for the inclusion of the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (UNDA) Shared Priorities Action Plan Measure (APM) 12 on safe, secure and equitable resource development.
- Natural Resources Canada (NRCan) has established a dedicated team to lead this measure and has begun early foundational work to guide its implementation.
Background
- The Final Report of the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women and Girls includes five Calls for Justice (13.1 to 13.5) focused specifically on the Extractive and Development Industries. They call for a comprehensive and collaborative approach to gain a better understanding of the impacts of natural resource projects and ensure the safety, security and socio-economic well-being of Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ peoples.
- While resource extraction presents a significant economic opportunity for local Indigenous communities, the National Inquiry also highlighted that resource development projects can exacerbate the problem of violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ peoples. There are several contributing factors such as: transient workers, harassment and sexual assault in the workplace, rotational shift work, substance abuse, and addictions and economic insecurity. Some studies about Indigenous and racialized women's experiences in mining camps show that "three-quarters of the women working in these industries have experienced discrimination based on gender, indigeneity, or sexual orientation".
- In 2022, the Standing Committee on the Status of Women (FEWO) conducted a study on this issue, resulting in the report : Responding to the Calls for Justice: Addressing Violence Against Indigenous Women and Girls in the Context of Resource Development Projects. It addresses a wide range of topics and provides recommendations that includes the involvement of federal, provincial, municipal jurisdictions, as well as private industry. Recommendations focus on Indigenous Rights, social infrastructure and service capacity, and increasing data collection, skills and representation in the natural resources sector. NRCan and CIRNAC co-led on the Government Response presented to the House on March 31st 2023, with input from thirteen other government departments.
- On June 21, 2023, the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act (UNDA) Action Plan was released, and includes four action plan measures (APMs) which touch on the natural resource sector. APM 12 specifically calls for safe, secure and equitable resource development for Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- In 2017, NRCan co-developed the Indigenous Advisory and Monitoring Committee for the Trans Mountain Expansion with Indigenous partners, in response to a request from communities to the Prime Minister. The Committee brings together 13 Indigenous and six senior federal representatives to provide advice to regulators and to monitor the Trans Mountain Expansion Project (TMX) and existing pipeline. A key priority of the Committee is identifying and addressing the impacts of temporary work camps and the influx of workers. This initiative has been highlighted in MMIWG Federal Pathway Annual Reports as responding to the five Calls for Justice on Extractive and Development Industries.
Current Status
- Natural Resources Canada has established a dedicated team to lead on APM 12, which has begun early foundational work to guide its implementation through:
- Partnering with the co-developed Trans Mountain Expansion and Existing Pipeline's Socio-economic Subcommittee to gather wise practices from their Work Camps and other Influxes of Workers Initiative;
- Initial engagement through relationship building with National Indigenous Women's Organizations including Pauktuutit Inuit Women of Canada, Native Women's Association of Canada and Les Femmes Michif Otipemisiwak as well as other Indigenous partners and communities;
- Partnering with Women and Gender Equality to draft indicators that will be used to inform the co-design of a performance measurement framework;
- Initiating the co-design of an engagement strategy with National Indigenous Women's Organizations, 2SLGBTQI+ organizations, natural resource industry associations, and others; and,
- Ensuring that all NRCan policies, programs and signature initiatives consider the perspectives of Indigenous women and 2SLGBTQI+ people and integrate safe, secure and equitable resource development priorities.
12. Overall Investments since 2015
This summary is intended to provide a sense of the diversity of federal actions taken across departments and agencies, beyond Crown-Indigenous Relations and Northern Affairs Canada. It is not comprehensive and does not capture investments and actions by Indigenous, provincial, territorial, or other partners.
Key Messages
- Addressing the disproportionate violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people continues to be a key priority for the government. Since 2015, the Government of Canada has passed various legislation, implemented programs, services and policies and made substantial investments to address the national crisis of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people (MMIWG2S+).
- Between 2016 and 2019, National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Women and Girls was funded and mandated to examine the systemic causes behind the violence against Indigenous women and girls. In response to the Inquiry's 2017 Interim Report, the government provided additional health supports; extending the Family Information Liaison Units; established a commemoration fund; reviewed police policies and practices; and, the established National Investigative Standards and Practices Unit within the RCMP.
- Subsequent to the release of the National Inquiry's report, the federal government made significant investments to address the Calls for Justice and support Indigenous organizations to be part of the development and implementation of the National Action Plan. This included investments in the Fall Economic Statement 2020, Budgets 2021, 2022, and 2023 for actions on shelters and housing, infrastructure, Indigenous languages, policing, mental health and wellbeing, access to health care, cultural spaces, the justice system and healing for families and survivors.
Background
- Since 2016, the government provided $103.8 million for the National Inquiry into Missing and Murdered Women and Girls (September 1, 2016 – April 30, 2019). This includes an additional $50 million the Inquiry requested for a two-year extension in March 2018.
- In response to the National Inquiry's Interim Report (November 2017) the following was provided: $21.3M over three years to complement the health supports provided by the Inquiry including $5.42M in 2019-20 to extend the timeframe of the Family Information Liaison Units and community-based supports; $10M over two years for a commemoration fund to honour the lives and legacies of Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ individuals; $1.25M for a review of police policies and practices; and, $9.6M over 5 years for a new National Investigative Standards and Practices Unit at the Royal Canadian Mounted Police.
- Subsequent to the release of the National Inquiry's Final Report, the government committed to developing a National Action Plan with Indigenous partners, as per Call for Justice 1.1. The government provided funding to support the participation of Indigenous partners in the development and implementation of the National Action Plan ($6 million per year).
- The 2020 Fall Economic Statement invested $781.5 million over five years, beginning in 2021–22, and $106.3 million ongoing. This ensured expansion of access to culturally relevant supports for Indigenous women, children and 2SLGBTQI+ people including shelters and transitional housing through the Comprehensive Violence Prevention Strategy; negotiation of administration of justice agreements; and implementation of the Gladue PrinciplesFootnote 2 and Indigenous-led responses in order to help reduce the overrepresentation of Indigenous Peoples in the criminal justice system.
- Budget 2021 funded a total of $2.2 billion over 5 years and $160.9 million ongoing to a number of activities to address MMIWG specifically such as:
- Cultural initiatives, i.e., revitalization and preservation of Indigenous languages; rehabilitation and building of cultural spaces and access to meaningful sports activities;
- health and wellness initiatives, i.e., activities to address anti-Indigenous racism in the health care system; and a new program to support the wellbeing of families and survivors;
- human safety and security initiatives, i.e., co-development of a legislative framework for First Nations policing; Indigenous-led crime prevention strategies and community safety services; and a new Pathways to Safe Indigenous Communities initiative.
- justice initiatives, i.e. support to help Indigenous families navigate the family justice system and access community-based family mediation services; development alongside Indigenous community of legislation and initiatives that address systemic barriers in the criminal justice system; and increasing prosecutorial capacity in the territories;
- a program to ensure the voices and perspectives of Indigenous women and 2SLGBTQI+ people are reflected in all aspects of decision-making and another to provide opportunities to ensure that monitoring mechanisms on addressing MMIWG (which included funding to establish an MMIWG Secretariat).
- Budget 2021 also took broader action that addresses the socio-economic root causes of violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people, such as improving access to education, and health and wellbeing services for Indigenous people; supporting the improvement of infrastructure; and support Indigenous entrepreneurs and economies.
- Budget 2022 provided continued support for Indigenous children and families and housing and infrastructure, and other activities that address the Calls for Justice.
- Budget 2023 supported a total amount of $124.7 million to support the following initiatives;
- Indigenous-led projects for safer communities through the Pathways to Safe Indigenous Communities Initiative;
- Family Information Liaison Units by making them a permanent resource for Indigenous people;
- the National Family and Survivors Circle to keep families and survivors at the centre of the implementation of the National Action Plan and the Federal Pathway;
- the establishment of a national Indigenous-Federal-Territorial-Indigenous Roundtable on MMIWG2S+ as a forum to discuss cross-jurisdictional issues related to MMIWG; and
- the development of an oversight mechanism to monitor and report on the progress on ending the violence.
Current Status
- Progress continues to be reported on in the Annual Progress Report on the Federal Pathway. The third Annual Progress Report is scheduled to be released on June 3, 2024.
13. Sunsetting Funding
Key Messages
- The federal government made significant investments through the 2020 Fall Economic Statement and Budget 2021 to support actions, initiatives and programs to end violence against Indigenous women girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
- These initiatives and programs are being led by over 20 federal departments and agencies and they continue to support concrete progress for Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people in areas such as shelters and housing, education, health care, and wellbeing.
- The Government of Canada is committed to accelerating efforts to end violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people.
Background
- The Federal Pathway was originally accompanied by funding announced in the 2020 Fall Economic Statement and Budget 2021. Since that time, some of these initiatives have begun to sunset.
- The Federal Pathway Annual Progress Report, released each year on June 3, provides a snapshot of the progress made and the linkages to the Calls for Justice. The Federal Pathway is an evergreen document that will evolve over time. Furthermore, the Horizontal Initiative on Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls, and 2SLGBTQI+ People (MMIWG), found in the Departmental Plan and Departmental Results Report, reports on common goals and outcomes. It also includes information on which programs have sunset.
- An example of a sunset program in 2022/23 is the Cultural Spaces in Indigenous Communities Program – which has supported 66 projects across the county to re-establish and revitalize Indigenous cultural spaces through a total of $108.8M,such as: New Multi-use Cultural Space (Mohawk Council of Kahnawà:ke; Quebec); Culture and Language Camps Project (Metis Nation of Ontario); Witset Youth Healing Lodge Project (Witset First National, British Columbia) ; and the Nunamiutuqaq - Building from the Land project (Kitikmeot Heritage Society, Cambridge Bay, Nunavut).
- Programs that are sunsetting in 2023/24 include:
- Addressing Anti-Indigenous Racism in Canada's Health Systems – total funding of $117.8M (ISC) and $14.9M. To date, Indigenous Services Canada has funded 157 projects nationally, in collaboration with 102 partners through Budget 2021, to begin addressing anti-Indigenous racism in health systems.
- Other sunsetting programs include: Distinctions-based mental wellness strategies and trauma-informed metal wellness services – total funding of $597.5M; and Affordable Housing in the North – total funding of $160M.
- The following are some examples of programs and initiatives announced in Budget 2021 that are scheduled to sunset in the coming years; however, this does not preclude the possibility that funding for any of these programs could be renewed.
- Funding currently scheduled to sunset 2024/25:
- Supporting Access to First Nations, Inuit and Métis Documentary Heritage- total funding: $14.9M.
- Community Infrastructure Fund – totally $4.3B
- Funding currently scheduled to sunset in 2025/26
- Pathways to Safe Indigenous Communities Initiative – totalling $103.8M
- Funding currently scheduled to sunset in 2026/27:
- funding for the establishment of a permanent MMIWG Secretariat – total funding: $16M
- Data Advisory Group and Indigenous-Led Data Research Projects Program – total funding: $8.5M.
- Self-Governing and Modern Treaty First Nations Housing Investment - total funding: $565M
- Funding currently scheduled to sunset in 2028/29:
- Inuit Housing Investment – total funding: $845M
- Métis Housing Investment - total funding: $190.2M
- There also are many federal government programs and initiatives that have ongoing funding, which are implemented on a continuous basis, such as:
- CIRNAC's Support for the Wellbeing of Families and Survivors of Missing and Murdered Indigenous Women, Girls and 2SLGBTQQIA+ People Contribution Program – ongoing funding: $2.5M annually – which has so far funded 34 Indigenous-led projects that provide assistance and services for the healing journeys of individual Indigenous family members and survivors who have missing or lost loved ones due to violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people;
- CIRNAC's Enhancing Support for Indigenous Women's and 2SLGBTQQIA+ Organizations – ongoing funding: $8.6M annually to provide stable project funding and support the amplification of the voices and perspectives of Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people in the development of policies, programs and legislation; and,
- The Department of Justice's Family Information Liaison Units which provide specialized services to families of missing and murdered Indigenous people to access all the available information about their missing and murdered loved ones, were funded by Budget 2023 with $95.8 M over five years, starting in 2023-24, and $20.4 M ongoing.
- Funding currently scheduled to sunset 2024/25:
Current Status
- While some of investments have begun to sunset, there are a number of ongoing programs and initiatives that are working to end the violence against Indigenous women, girls and 2SLGBTQI+ people. In addition new investments continue to be announced, that have extended earlier sunsetting programs or initiatives, such as the Budget 2023 investments to support the Family Information Liaison Units.
14. Truth and Reconciliation Commission Calls to Action
Key Messages
- Over 85% of the Calls to Action under shared or sole responsibility of the federal government are complete or well underway.
- These actions are leading to significant and consequential changes that serve to redress the legacy of residential schools and advance the process of reconciliation.
- Completing all 94 Calls to Action requires fundamental policy and legislative changes to address systematic barriers.
Background
- In 2015, upon the release of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission's Final Report, the Prime Minister committed to work in partnership with Indigenous communities, the provinces, territories, and other vital partners, to fully implement the Commission's Calls to Action. Canada has adopted a whole-of-government approach to implementing the TRC Calls to Action.
- Of the 94 Calls to Action, 76 are shared or sole responsibility of the federal government and 15 are led by Crown-Indigenous Relations and Norther Affairs Canada.
- In 2021, the Minister of Crown Indigenous Relations was tasked with leading federal work to accelerate the implementation of all Calls to Action.
Current Status
- Bill C-29, legislation to provide for the establishment of the National Council for Reconciliation, has been in the House of Commons for consideration of amendments adopted by the Senate since November 2023. Debates have been held in February and March. Once established, the National Council for Reconciliation will be an independent, Indigenous-led, not-for-profit organization working to monitor and advance reconciliation in Canada (Calls to Action 53 through 56).
- Collaboration is ongoing with departments to identify the necessary steps to accelerate implementation, address systemic challenges hindering progress, and involve all partners (Indigenous, all levels of government, etc.) in responding to the Calls to Action.
- The Government of Canada continues to work with the Permanent Bilateral Mechanisms with First Nations, Inuit and Métis Leaders to collaborate on joint priorities; co-develop policy and monitor progress; and, encourage implementation of the Calls to Action.